I’m a planner. When it comes to activities, I’ve always liked to plan ahead.
As a hiker/climber/backpacking tent-camper, I’d sit down in the spring and map out every weekend and vacation adventure through the end of autumn and beyond. The need for preplanning got worse when Dianne and I bought a trailer.
In the old days, any place we could park our truck became a potential campsite. Other than an occasional national park stay, we had no need to bunk in formal campgrounds. That’s tougher with the trailer.
These days, we need a nice flat spot to park our motel on wheels, ideally with water spigot nearby. With solar panels and/or a generator, we can go without a power hookup, but a dump station for draining the holding tanks is a handy amenity if we’re staying more than a few days.
We’re not big fans of RV parks where “campers” are parked elbow-to-elbow like cars in a Costco parking lot. We prefer state parks, where sites are typically spaced farther apart and often cloaked in vegetation. For most state parks, ensuring a site requires making a reservation sometimes up to a year in advance.
The problem with planning one’s life that far ahead is that as Forest Gump pointed out, sometimes “stuff happens.” Take the latest pandemic, for example. By the end of 2019, I had our camping for 2020 totally scheduled, with campsites reserved through late September.
We’re now rebooking things. We had a long-planned trip with friends to an Arizona state park in April, timed so that we would be there for their annual wine and food tasting event. We had to cancel one week before departure when Colorado was put on a shelter-in-place lockdown. We rescheduled our reservations for October.
This week, another trip bit the dust. We were planning to meet some friends at a trailer rally in South Dakota in mid-June with stops at a Nebraska state park on the way up and a week-long retreat in the Black Hills on our way back. That trip will now be held next year, virus-permitting. Instead of South Dakota, we found a site still open at a Colorado state park and booked it for the same time period.
A late-May trip to Robb State Park in Grand Junction, Colorado, is still on our calendar at this point, although the scope of the trip has changed. As baseball fans, we originally planned to attend a few games of the Junior College World Series while we were there, but that event has, of course, been cancelled. If the campground reopens, we’ll still go and just do a lot of hiking instead.
Beyond that, we still have campsites reserved for July in Colorado. In mid-August, we have reservations for a six-week swing down the Left Coast with stops at state parks in Oregon and California with a couple of weeks camped in the redwoods before continuing on for our rescheduled Arizona trip.
While we may not be camping in the trailer, I am taking the time to “improve” our motel-on-wheels. In the next few weeks, I’ll be installing an upgraded toilet, reinforcing the bumper, moving the spare tire to below the frame and bolting on a receiver for a bike rack. I’ll probably be replacing the refrigerator thermistor with an adjustable version, installing a pair of solar panel inputs at the rear of the trailer and adding a sliding silverware drawer.
I’m also thinking about spending our covid-incentive on upgrading my factory power center converter/charger with a Progressive Dynamics unit and replacing a pair of anemic, lead-acid batteries with a 200-amp lithium-ion unit. That will allow us to boonie-camp for longer periods without needing to pull out the solar panels or fire up the generator.
Now, if we could just solve the need for a dump station, but unfortunately, Dianne is too excited about using that new, upgraded toilet for that ever to happen.
The Most Exciting Way to Experience the Grand Canyon May be in a Wooden Boat
Like a liquid freight train that’s jumped its tracks, the entire flow of the Colorado River careens toward the canyon’s far wall. Beyond, it shakes and churns down a channel choked with submerged boulders. Between those rocks and the hard place froths enough hydrological mayhem to flip the Queen Mary.
Expedition
leader Bill Bruchak guides our tiny boat toward the left side of the flow. With a series of hefty pulls, he rows stern-first
into the agitated bedlam. Engulfed in
turbulence, Bruchak yanks an oar, and we pirouette to go with the current.
Ahead stands a wave taller than a suburban tract home. As we graze its side, water arcs down, filling the foot wells 15 inches deep. A series of rolling tail waves follow. Like the mechanical bull at Gilley’s, the boat bucks through each swell with all onboard screaming “HEE-HAW!”
We finally
reach the eddy at cataract’s end, and I’m beaming. House Rock Rapid has just given me an exhilarating
taste of how dories cruise through white water.
The
sports cars of commercial river running, dories are made from wood, foam and
fiberglass. They stand about 18 feet long,
56 inches wide and comfortably hold four passengers and an oarsman. A flat bottom and upturned ends make them
easy to steer on the river, and because they have rigid hulls, they don’t flex
with the waves as rubber rafts will.
Instead, a sharp prow splits the water in a way that makes even riffles
exciting. Unlike inflatables, however,
these rigid-walled craft can crack on rocks, so dory drivers must carefully
plot routes through rapids.
“They’re
a royal pain sometimes, but they’re worth it because of the ride you get,” says
guide Shawn Browning.
On this Grand Canyon Dories journey through the length of the canyon, we have four boats for 16 clients, rowed by a three-man, one-woman crew of seasoned guides. The bulk of our gear travels onboard a pair of oar-powered baggage rafts.
Our first
camp lies on a riverside beach two miles below the rapid. In a drill that’s repeated for 17 nights, everyone
first unloads gear and waterproof “dry bags” from the rafts. While we seek sleeping sites, the cooking team
begins preparing a fresh-food dinner in a portable kitchen, complete with
propane stove and lantern. The boatmen assemble
water-purification and hand-washing stations, then find a secluded yet scenic
spot for the portable potty. Nicknamed “The
Unit,” this toilet-seat-on-an-ammo-can offers a throne with a view.
We spend evenings circled around a campfire. The Milky Way shimmers overhead, its luminescence painting the gaps between inky canyon walls. Civilization fades far away.
Most
mornings, I awaken to the descending notes of a canyon wren. After coffee and a hot breakfast, we load
boats and head downstream. Calm current and
raging white water await.
Rapids
occur near the mouths of side canyons where flashfloods have washed rocks and
rolled boulders into the river. We porpoise
through most like dolphins on pep pills.
If the boat hits waves straight on, the prow shoots high into the air with
nothing but blue above the bow.
Grand Canyon cataracts are rated on a 10-point technical scale,
with “one” being a dancing riffle and “10” a slobbering ogre ready to devour
anything floating through. I soon
develop my own “fun-factor” rating system based on how many inches of water
occupy the foot well at rapid’s end.
Although pros operate the oars, dory passengers play a part in running rapids. We are responsible for “high siding,” a weight-shifting maneuver that helps keep the boats from tipping.
“If a big
wave’s coming right at the side of the boat, you want to lean into it,” says guide
Elena Kirschner. “That means you’re
going to get wet and cold, but it’s a lot less wet and cold than swimming in
the river.”
Fortunately,
dories seldom flip, and unlike rafts, they are easy to turn right-side up. None of ours tip over, but a private raft
trip that launched the same day we did experiences several upsets.
“There’ve
been some deaths on the river by drowning and being hit,” says Martin Litton,
the man who introduced dories to the canyon.
“Nearly all of them have occurred in inflatable rafts.”
In 1869,
Major John Wesley Powell led the canyon’s first float trip in wooden boats. Built for straight-line speed, his craft proved
unwieldy in rapids. Other river runners followed,
each generation improving its predecessor’s designs. It took almost a century for dories to reach
the canyon.
“I’d seen
these McKenzie boats in Oregon
made out of plywood,” explains Litton. “We
got a builder to craft a couple of hulls, and in 1962 we made the first trip in
dories.”
Litton
soon began annual river-running vacations, taking along friends, friends of
friends and people he’d never seen before.
To keep from going broke, he started charging $180 for his 21-day
trips. In late 1968, he quit his senior
editor job at Sunset magazine.
“I just
walked out,” he says. “From then on, I
was in the business of running river trips.”
His company, Grand Canyon Dories, became a leader in the burgeoning industry of white-water river running. In the late 1980s, Litton sold the operation to O.A.R.S., which continues to offer a full schedule of trips.
If rapids
provide the river’s caffeine, flat stretches are its herbal tea. In the calm between the cataracts, we relax
as oars stroke the water in metronome rhythm.
Great blue herons stand by the shore watching our passage. Bighorn sheep gaze down from above. Rock walls reach upward, their colors and
textures revealing the canyon’s geological history. We float through nature’s gallery, displayed
at its artistic best.
“If this
was all flat water, I’d like it just as much,” admits baggage-boat oarsman Kurt
Brooks.
Although
we stop at the canyon’s famous spots, it’s not the guidebook highlights that prove
most memorable. It’s the secret places. We climb to overlooks and hike side canyons
to waterfall grottos. We see where
geologic faults have bent rock as if it was made of taffy. We examine prehistoric petroglyphs,
pictographs and Indian ruins, as well as remains left by miners, railroad
surveyors and would-be dam builders.
Conventional
civilization lies in abeyance. Only on
day eight when we reach Phantom Ranch, an inner-canyon lodge, is our wilderness
interrupted. There, surrounded by hikers
and mule riders, we buy lemonade, T-shirts and postcards. Escaping back into the wild, we camp for the
night below Horn Creek Rapid, one of the canyon’s more challenging cataracts. The worst lie ahead.
The next
day, we cover what Bruchak claims is “the biggest navigable water for a dory in
North America.” In 23 miles we navigate 16
named rapids that include several of the canyon’s gnarliest. I ride with Browning.
After breezing through Salt Creek Rapid, we hit Granite, a boiling pot of froth and turbulence. Browning aims down the tongue, but misses the line by a few inches. Nipping “the crasher,” he spins around. Suddenly, we’re rushing stern-first toward a very hard wall.
“Schist!”
I shout, naming the rock strata lying dead ahead.
Browning
pulls the oars with every adrenaline-packed ounce of energy he can muster. But the river is stronger.
WHAM! We hit with an impact that would make a demolition
derby driver wince. The collision spins
us again so we’re now moving forward. Browning
catches the current, and we finally jolt out the bottom of the rapid. Opening the stern hatch, I expect to see a
Titanic-size hole, but it’s dry. We’re
only bruised, not busted.
“Yikes, that was close,” Browning says in what
may be the understatement of the day.
Downstream,
we ride Hermit’s 35-foot-tall wave train without incident. After an inconsequential run through Boucher,
we arrive at Crystal. Once, this was little more than a riffle, but
a 1966 flashflood choked the river with debris, forming one of the canyon’s most
gut wrenching cataracts.
“At high water, Crystal is a difficult rapid with dire consequences if you blow it,” says Browning. “We’re at medium-low water, so we’re going to do what is called the left run. It’s big.”
We
pull into the current, nipping the edge of a gaping hole. Water crashes down. Like Niagara
Falls hitting a teacup, the boat fills from gunwale-to-gunwale
rendering it too heavy to maneuver. Boat-shredding
boulders loom below.
“BAIL!” Browning
cries. “BAIL! BAIL!”
We begin
madly flinging water over the sides. Our
compatriots say it looks like hoses spraying from a fireboat. We lighten the craft enough to safely negotiate
the final white water. At the bottom, we
mercifully say our ABCs – Alive Below Crystal.
After
lunch, we plow through a succession of cataracts, missing walls, rocks and
holes. It’s a repetitive cycle of
anticipation and anxiety followed by jubilation and relief. If the dories are sports cars, this is their Le Mans.
I fall asleep, confident that our spunky guides and spritely craft can handle anything the canyon throws at it. That’s good, because the most feared rapid lies three days downstream.
Once, molten
magma dammed the Colorado, but the relentless river eroded away the impediment,
leaving only a surging drop called Lava Falls in its wake. While not the most technically upsetting
rapid, it’s the one that drives more boatmen to hit the Maalox.
“Every
time I make that turn and hear the roar, my heart jumps 15 beats faster,” says Bruchak,
with whom I ride today.
The
cataract looks like a blender churning milkshakes in the river. We slowly approach the lip of the cataclysm
like condemned prisoners on a gurney.
“Hang
on,” he says. “We’re getting close. Get ready!”
We teeter
at the brink, then swoop into the Cuisinart chaos. A ledge to the left has formed a gaping maw
in the river. Bruchak pulls the dory to
the edge of it, gaining momentum.
“Get
ready! Big one!”
We sever
a lateral wave and slice down to where two currents rush together to form a bulging
V-wave. The bow rises. Water flies.
We bounce like an ice cube in a martini shaker.
“Bigger
one coming! Hang on! BIGGER ONE.”
We plow
through a second, larger V-wave. Torrents
crash by the boat’s bow. I grip the
gunwales so tightly, I expect to leave indentations in the hardwood. We bound, bounce and bash through the rapid’s
gut, finally exiting through the tail waves.
Nine seconds
after it began, it’s over. Bruchak pulls
into the eddy and everyone breathes a triumphant sigh of relief.
“There’s
no place on the river like that,” he exclaims, grinning.
I look at the bottom of the boat. Only four inches of water slosh in the foot well. Maybe Lava Falls isn’t so bad after all.
Arizona’s Superstition Mountains LieLacedwith the Legends of Lost Lodes
It was my
first ever hike. I was nine years old
when my father’s friend, Scotty, invited us to join him on a trek into the Superstition Mountains,
a rugged jumble of bluffs, buttes, crags, cliffs and canyons rising 35 miles
east of Phoenix. Naturally, I wore my Roy Rogers cowboy
boots. Six blisters later, I realized
why Roy rode
and seldom walked. Only Scotty’s tales
of treasure kept me going.
As every Arizona kid of my era
knew, the Superstitions held the Lost Dutchman Mine, and Scotty was an expert
on this missing treasure trove. He led
us into an area known as the Massacre Grounds where the story got its start.
According to Scotty, the Peralta family from Mexico opened 18 mines in the Superstitions from which they extracted gold in unbelievable quantities. Their last foray, a procession of 400 men and 200 pack mules, came in 1847. On their return, they were ambushed, their gold was scattered and their mines were soon covered over. Skeletons, rotten saddlebags and $18,000 in loose, gold-veined concentrates found later in the area support the story’s accuracy.
The only
thing we discovered on our adventure was an arrowhead and a shallow cave whose
campfire-sooted walls stood black as a chalkboard. Somebody spent many nights camped here. I figured it was the Dutchman.
As the
story goes, two German prospectors, Jacob Waltz and Jacob Wieser, drifted into
a small Mexican village where they rescued a man from a barroom brawl. In gratitude, the saved señor, a Peralta
relative, gave the partners a map and ultimately rights to the family’s Arizona diggings. The two Germans headed north, and in a land
so rugged that even a lizard could get lost, they found the Peralta site left
uncovered. It held, according to Waltz,
an 18-inch vein of pure gold.
“World’s
richest mine,” he bragged.
Wieser’s
good fortune remained short lived. With Waltz
allegedly out buying supplies, someone murdered Wieser. All the gold now belonged to the “Dutchman,”
whose nickname either came from Deutsch,
the German word for German, or his contemporaries bore a worse sense of
geography than today’s sixth-graders.
I’ve logged
hundreds of trail miles in the Superstitions since that first experience. Today, I’m introducing my wife, Dianne, to
the area. As Scotty did for me, I’m sharing
with her tales of the Dutchman and the “Dutch hunters” who followed.
Our
springtime hike from the First Water Trailhead begins, appropriately, on a
trail named for the Dutchman. The cool
morning air carries the fragrance of wildflowers. Mourning doves coo plaintive dirges in the
distance.
Although
historical records cannot confirm Wieser’s or the mine’s existence, Waltz was a
very real person. Born in Germany, he immigrated to the U.S. in 1839. A decade later, he headed west for the California gold rush, obtaining American citizenship in Los Angeles. He later moved to Prescott, Arizona,
where he filed mining claims.
In his snow-bearded
years, Waltz settled down in Phoenix to raise
chickens on a 160-acre plot near the Salt River. The stream flooded in 1891, and Waltz spent two
frigid nights in a tree before being rescued.
He contracted pneumonia from the incident.
Julia
Thomas, a German-speaking ice-cream parlor owner, cared for the ailing
Dutchman. After eight months’ convalescence,
the 81-year-old Waltz took a turn for the worse. Prior to cashing in, the Dutchman attempted
to disclose his mine’s whereabouts, but all he ended up bequeathing were vague
directions and a few pounds of gold-laced rock.
Firmly believing she could find his mine,
Thomas sold her shop and rode into the Superstitions the following August. Waltz’s deathbed instructions ultimately proved
impossible to follow. After repeated
searches, Thomas did the next best thing.
She sold maps to the mine she couldn’t find.
Our trail
parallels First Water Creek as it whispers through rock-lined pools. Come summer, the creek will be deathly
dry. I know because like Julia Thomas
and a slew of other Dutch hunters, I’ve hiked here in the height of heat.
Years
ago, a group of us wanted to see what it would be like to explore the
wilderness when temperatures topped triple digits. It wasn’t fun. By the time we reached our campsite, we were sizzling
like pigs at a luau. We spent the
remainder of the day simmering away beneath a cottonwood tree.
Dianne
and I cross Parker Pass and head down to Boulder Basin,
an open area studded with cactus and laced with wildflowers. A short detour up East Boulder Creek takes us
to the site of Aylor’s Caballo Camp.
Arriving
from Colorado,
Chuck and Peg Aylor moved into the Superstitions in 1939 hoping to find the
Dutchman’s lost diggings. They remained
here until the Forest Service evicted them in the 1960s and dismantled their
camp. Although the Aylors found nothing
of value, they at least left alive. Many
were not so lucky. One of the most
famous of the dearly departed was Adolph Ruth.
A retired
bureaucrat from Washington,
D.C., Adolph Ruth came in 1931 with
an old map his son had obtained from a Mexican diplomat. He arrived in mid-June and immediately hired a
couple of cowboys to pack him into the Superstitions. A week later, a rancher found his camp empty. Ruth was nowhere to be seen.
A 45-day
search ensued with no results. Six
months later, members of an archeology expedition found a skull several canyons
away, which authorities confirmed was Ruth’s.
Bullet holes punctured both sides of the cranium.
The rest
of his skeleton and personal effects turned up a half-mile away. In one pocket was a sheet of paper on which
Ruth had written “Veni, Vidi, Vici” (I came, I saw, I conquered). His map was missing.
Dianne
and I continue our hike over Bull Pass and down into Needle Canyon. A buzzard circles overhead, perhaps hoping
that we, too, are doomed Dutch hunters. We
aim to disappoint.
Weavers
Needle, icon of the Superstitions, towers to the south. In the shadow of this thousand-foot-high
volcanic monolith, two rival groups battled in the 1950s over lost gold, but
not from a mine. They sought a treasure allegedly
stashed by priests.
After King Carlos III evicted the Jesuits from
New Spain in 1767, a missionary-led pack train
supposedly entered the Superstitions with 240 heavily burdened mules. When the convoy reemerged, the animals bore
no loads. The toted treasure, the opposing
factions figured, must be hidden in these hills.
One heavily armed band was led by Celeste Jones, a black woman who claimed to have studied music at Juilliard and sung with the Metropolitan Opera. She traipsed about the mountains in sneakers, Bermuda shorts, sunglasses and a wide-brimmed hat. Jones believed gold lay hidden in Weavers Needle, guarded by a band of people visible only to her. To win their favor, she serenaded them.
Ed Piper,
a lanky white prospector, led the opposing armed camp. He generally donned khaki trousers and, like
Jones, always sported a sidearm. He was
an accomplished farmer and planted fruit trees in the desert near the base of Weavers
Needle. Both groups shared the area’s
sole water source.
Animosity
peaked when Piper killed one of Jones’ men.
He was questioned, but for lack of witnesses, the court ruled
self-defense. Diagnosed with stomach
cancer, Piper left in 1962 and died two months later. Jones stayed another year before departing
the Superstitions for good.
We follow
Boulder Canyon downstream to the Second Water
Trail, our return route to the trailhead.
Afternoon light glints off cholla and saguaro needles. Butterflies flutter among purple-flowered
thistles, globe mallows add dollops of orange and century plants stalk upward
in their single reproductive shot before death.
“Does
the mine really exist?” Dianne asks.
Scant documentary
evidence exists to support the existence of Dutchman’s diggings. No claim was ever filed, and tax records show
Waltz claimed only around $200 in personal property. But folks occasionally lie to assessors, and locals
saw Waltz brandishing gold from somewhere.
“I
believe there is a Lost Dutchman Mine,” Mike Smith, who formerly managed a
local prospecting supply store, once told me.
“There are enough facts to conclude something is out there.”
Critics
speculate that Waltz may have stolen ore from the Vulture Mine northwest of Phoenix. Others contend the Dutchman’s nuggets came
from a mine in Goldfield, four miles north of Apache Junction.
“That
was a possibility,” Smith countered, “but Dr. Tom Glover did electron
dispersal analysis of ores from Goldfield and the Vulture. None matched the Dutchman’s.”
Longtime
Dutch hunter Ron Feldman, owner of Apache Junction’s OK Corral stables, suggested
to me that the Dutchman’s mine may already have been totally gutted in the ’20s.
“Think
about it,” he argues. “If you
found the mine and staked a claim, foes would come right to you. Your best bet would be to keep your mouth
shut.”
History may never reveal the truth of the Dutchman’s gold, which is fine by me. The lingering mystery offers a inexhaustible excuse to poke around this inspiring El Dorado. After all, as Scotty pointed out on my first hike years ago, “If failure foiled dreamers, no one would drop a second quarter in a slot machine.”
After 26 years of full-time, freelance travel writing, I’ve decided it’s time to finally hit the brakes. Instead of researching stories, I’m going to visit places just for the sheer joy of being there. No more interviews to schedule. No more copious notes to take. No more casting for storylines.
Park name sign, Kartchner Caverns State Park, Benson, Arizona.Campsite 24, Kartchner Caverns State Park, Benson, Arizona.Sunset light on the cliffs of Pusch Ridge, Catalina State Park, Tucson, Arizona.Shuttle tram, Sabino Canyon, Tucson, Arizona.Hikers on the Kent Springs Trail, Madera Canyon, Arizona.Old prison honor camp, Gordon Hirabayashi Recreation Site, Santa Catalina Mountains, Tucson, Arizona.Brett and Mick on Sycamore Reservoir Trail, Santa Catalina Mountains, Tucson, Arizona.Dianne Leeth hikes Molino Basin Trail, Santa Catalina Mountains, Tucson, Arizona.Echinopsis thelegona cactus, Tucson Botanical Gardens, Tucson, Arizona.Chapel, DeGrazia Gallery in the Sun, Tucson, Arizona.Chapel wall mural, DeGrazia Gallery in the Sun, Tucson, Arizona.Inside galleries, DeGrazia Gallery in the Sun, Tucson, Arizona.Inside galleries, DeGrazia Gallery in the Sun, Tucson, Arizona.Ferruginous hawk (Buteo regalis), Arizona-Sonora Desert Museum, Tucson, Arizona.Barn owl (Tyto alba), Arizona-Sonora Desert Museum, Tucson, Arizona.Isla San Esteban chuckwalla (Sauromalus varius), Arizona-Sonora Desert Museum, Tucson, Arizona.Speckled rattlesnake (Crotalus mitchellii), Arizona-Sonora Desert Museum, Tucson, Arizona.Sunset, Catalina State Park, Tucson, Arizona.
Tower Arch, Klondike Bluffs Trail, Arches National Park, Moab, Utah.Devil’s Garden Campground, Arches National Park, Moab, Utah.Balanced Rock at dawn, Arches National Park, Moab, Utah.Balloon over the cliffs, Arches National Park, Moab, Utah.Dianne Leeth at Broken Arch, Arches National Park, Moab, Utah.Devil’s Garden Trail, Arches National Park, Utah.Devil’s Garden Trail, Arches National Park, Utah.Private Arch, Devil’s Garden Trail, Arches National Park, Utah.Dead juniper and moon, Devil’s Garden Campground, Arches National Park, Moab, Utah.Skyline Arch at sunset from Devil’s Garden Campground, Arches National Park, Moab, Utah.
Inside the dugout, John Jarvie Historic Property, Browns Park, Utah.
Chicken coop, John Jarvie Historic Property, Browns Park, Utah.
Water wheel, John Jarvie Historic Property, Browns Park, Utah.
Trailer in campsite 34, Thomas Creek Campground, Lamoile Canyon, Ruby Mountains near Elko, Nevada.
Waterfall in Thomas Creek, Thomas Canyon Trail, Lamoile Canyon in the Ruby Mountains near Elko, Nevada.
Peaks by moonlight, campsite 34, Thomas Creek Campground, Lamoile Canyon, Ruby Mountains near Elko, Nevada.
Redfish Lake at dusk, Sawtooth National Recreation Area, Stanley, Idaho.
Peaks along the Redfish Lake Creek Trail, Sawtooth National Recreation Area, Stanley, Idaho.
Dead trees and grass, Fishhook Creek Trail, Sawtooth National Recreational Area, Stanley, Idaho.
Beach at dusk, Bear Lake State Park, Rendezvous Beach, Garden City, Utah.
Front porch of main house, Swett Ranch National Historic site, Flaming Gorge National Recreation Area near Dutch John, Utah.
Old John Deere farm equipment, Swett Ranch National Historic site, Flaming Gorge National Recreation Area near Dutch John, Utah.
From the bottom of the dam looking up, Flaming Gorge Dam, Flaming Gorge National Recreation Area, Dutch John, Utah.
Flaming Gorge Reservoir in Red Canyon at dusk, Red Canyon Visitor Center, Ashley National Forest, Flaming Gorge National Recreation Area near Dutch John, Utah.
View from the boat, Flaming Gorge Reservoir, Flaming Gorge National Recreation Area near Dutch John, Utah.
Raft floats the Green River, Little Hole Trail, Ashley National Forest, Flaming Gorge National Recreation Area near Dutch John, Utah.
Tower Rock, Sheep Creek Canyon Geological Area, Ashley National Forest, Utah.
Ute Mountain Fire Tower National Historial Site, Ashley National Forest, Utah.
The Cumbres & Toltec Scenic Railroad Offers a Colorful Autumn Excursion on Tracks Through the Past
In the movie “Back to the Future,” a plutonium-powered DeLorean sportscar catapulted Michael J. Fox’s character, Marty McFly, 30 years into the past. Onboard the Cumbres & Toltec Scenic Railroad, a coal-fired locomotive does a similar thing, transporting me and my fellow passengers a century and more back in time.
The longest and loftiest narrow-gauge route remaining in the country, the Cumbres & Toltec snakes back and forth along the state line between Antonito, Colorado, and Chama, New Mexico. Just as passengers have done since the train’s inception, we hear steam-driven pistons throb and wheels clack as cars sway down the tracks. Billowing smoke from the boiler scents the air with the heady aroma of burning coal. Over most of its 64-mile route, there are no paved roads, no powerlines and to the dismay of social-media addicted teens, no WiFi, internet or cell coverage. A panorama of wilderness-worthy scenery passes by in blissfully slow motion.
“It’s the past as far as the eye can see in
any direction,” observes Cumbres & Toltec president John Bush. “It’s this eddy in the current of time.”
The route dates back to the early 1880s when the
Denver & Rio Grande Railroad laid tracks linking Colorado’s capital with the
mining mecca of Silverton. Rather than using
standard gauge with rails spread 56½ inches apart, the Denver & Rio Grande placed
its rails 36 inches apart so their trains could make tighter turns through sinuous
mountain terrain. While many of the line’s
narrow-gauge tracks were later converted to standard, the route between Antonito
and Silverton remained unmodified. Today,
the preserved sections from Durango to Silverton and Antonito to Chama offer
scenic escapes into a bygone time.
Unlike its more northerly sister, which follows the Animas River through a lush canyon, the Cumbres & Toltec climbs through the mountains with sweeping views of hills and valleys along the way. Come fall, those slopes glisten with the Midas-touched leaves of autumn aspen.
“Riding this train is on my
bucket list,” an excited passenger told me over breakfast at the vintage Steam
Train Hotel in Antonito.
One-way Cumbres & Toltec journeys depart daily from either end. On this journey, I chose to head westbound from Antonito, which allowed me to watch herds of pronghorn dart across the San Luis Valley in the crisp light of morning. After the conductor punched my ticket, I left my reserved seat in a closed passenger car and headed for the open gondola where docents from Friends of the Cumbres & Toltec provide a commentary about what we’re seeing. As we approached a wooden trestle five miles from town, docent Bob Ross related a tale of its multiple monikers.
“There are two stories, the first of which I don’t believe,” he admitted. “Theoretically in 1880, they hung a guy named Ferguson off this trestle. That’s why they called it Hangman’s or Ferguson’s Trestle. The second story is definitely true. Willy Nelson made a movie out here in 1988 called ‘Where the Hell is That Gold.’ During the filming, they accidently burned the trestle down. So, they had to build us a new one. We now call it the Willie Nelson Trestle.”
A trackside sign soon revealed that
we’d passed into New Mexico, the first 11 border crossings. We’d gained several hundred feet in altitude,
and the sage and rabbitbrush of the San Luis Valley were giving way to piñon
and juniper. Crossing back into Colorado, we rounded Whiplash Curve, a series of
horseshoe-shaped loops needed to maintain an ascent angle of less than 1½
percent or roughly 80 vertical feet per linear mile.
As the piñon and juniper slowly surrendered
territory to ponderosa pine, we were treated to sneak peeks of the autumn magnificence
that lingered ahead. Trackside willows shimmered
with gilded leaves. Nuggets of golden aspen
began to salt slopes and line the tracks.
A motherlode of 24-karat color sluiced down hillsides beyond.
The train stopped at the former railroad station of Sublette to take on water. Here, in seemingly the middle of nowhere, stands the home where a section foreman and his family once lived year-round. There were seven such section houses between Antonito and Chama, but only three remain. They have all been restored by the Friends along with trackside signs, whistle boards and mileage markers along the route.
“About 10 years ago we were out here painting the mileposts,” Ross told us. “All of a sudden, we heard something and looked up the hill. A mountain lion was staring down at us from maybe 50 feet away. Fortunately, the lion was not hungry, and we were able to get out of there without any problems.”
One of the advantages of narrow-gauge trackage was that many obstacles could be rounded and tunnels avoided. There are two exceptions on the Cumbres & Toltec. The first is the 342-foot-long Mud Tunnel, so named because it was bored through soft, loose volcanic material. It needed to be lined with heavy timbers to keep ceilings and walls from caving in. It, too, was featured in Willie Nelson’s movie. Fortunately, his pyro-crew avoided setting this one aflame.
We rounded a curve lined with freestanding rock pillars known as hoodoos. These monoliths cast eerie shadows in locomotive headlights at night, causing crewmen to christen it “Phantom Curve.”
Three miles later, we reached a bar
hanging above the tracks with weighted ropes dangling down. Called a telltale, its purpose was to bonk
the heads of brakemen walking atop boxcar roofs, warning them to duck. Rock Tunnel lay just ahead.
The 366-foot, curving shaft was blasted through solid igneous rock and needed no shoring. Immediately beyond, we enjoyed a quick glimpse into Toltec Gorge where sheer cliffs plummet 600 feet to the canyon’s floor. A sign asks passengers to not throw rocks as there may be fishermen below. Beyond stands a monument to James A. Garfield, America’s second president to be assassinated in office.
A bit past high noon, both the
westbound and eastbound trains converge at Osier Station where a hot lunch,
included in the ticket price, is served.
Here, the railroad built a section house and depot, which the Friends
have restored and opened to visitors.
While we stuff stomachs, wrench-wielding
crewmen oiled bearings, checked brakes and attended to other maintenance needs. Unlike a living history museum where staff
mimic tasks for show, crewmen on the Cumbres & Toltec perform the very same
jobs their forebearers did to keep the trains running. Not only are the tasks the same, but many of
the employees come from families who have worked on the railroad for
generations, including our conductor’s son who’s a fifth-generation railway worker.
Back onboard, we crossed the 13-story-high Cascade Trestle, looped a hill, circled a meadow and chugged past a few summer homes. Here we got our first glimpse of Highway 17 connecting Antonito and Chama. Topping Tanglefoot Curve, we crossed the highway and stopped for water atop 10,015-foot Cumbres Pass where a depot, section house and other historic buildings still stand.
Cumbres Pass was a busy place in the old days. Because long, eastbound freight trains couldn’t ascend the four-percent grade from Chama, cars needed to be uncoupled in town and hauled up a dozen or so up at a time. When all the cars were atop Cumbres, they would be reconnected to a single locomotive and hauled down to Antonito and beyond. Even today, if more than eight cars are in the train, the railroad has to use a double-header arrangement up Cumbres with a pair of locomotives linked together to power the train to the top of the hill.
Departing Cumbres, we wound around
Windy Point and began our steep descent toward Chama. The open valley beyond looked like a giant fruit
bowl bursting with shades of lime green, lemon yellow and tangerine
orange. The pavement winding below
provided a silvery bow through this cornucopia of color. Where tracks recrossed the highway at the
bottom stood a gaggle of camera-toting railroad groupies. Like paparazzi shadowing stars in a
Technicolor blockbuster, they filled their memory cards with pictures of us as
we chugged by.
Passing the Cresco Water Tank, we entered New Mexico for the final time. The land flattened out. I saw cattle grazing near the tracks, some of which looked as hairy as a Summer of Love hippie. They’re Asian yaks being bred for meat.
We passed the fake, movie-set water-tower
pipe that the young Indy swung from in “Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade.” No fewer than 15 movies have been filmed on
the Cumbres & Toltec line.
After traversing a narrow section
of the route, appropriately named the Narrows, we cross the Chama River on a
steel-truss bridge, waved to campers at the Rio Chama RV Park and entered the
rail yard where locomotives and scores of bygone freight cars line the sidings.
The present-day world awaited, but
unlike Marty McFly, I didn’t need a silvery DeLorean to power me there. A thoroughly modern bus idled beside the
depot, ready to whisk me and my fellow passengers back to the 21st
century.